A peaceful day

Phillipians 4:4-8

For with Thee is the fountain of life; in Thy light shall we see light. Psalm 36:9
12.1.12

The Mummy Song

Posted by Jeanne

We started Jeannie Fulbright's Exploring Creation with Anatomy and Physiology book today. Jemimah is excited to be learning about the human body, and was rather disgusted to discover that today's lesson was an introductory lesson covering the history of medicine rather than launching straight into the blood, guts and gore. Oh well. Soon kid, soon.

We looked at the ancient Egyptians and Hebrews today, and I was surprised to learn how much Jemimah knew about the Egyptians and their process of mummification. She knew more than I do, that's for sure.

Well, after impressing me with her superior knowledge, she finally confessed that all she knows was gleaned here.



Yep, it's Horrible Histories - I should have known! This, I whisper quietly behind my hand, is one of my daughter's favourite shows. She likes the books too, but the telly is better, she says. I think I would be more critical of the series if it were not for the information that Jemimah has learned and retained from watching them. She knows the names of all the English kings, for example. Which is pretty impressive, me thinks, if you want a party trick.

The author of the books, Terry Deary, freely admits that his books are designed to "entertain first, and inform second", by concentrating on the unusual, the gory, the amusing, and the unpleasant. They're everything I don't like in a book, filled as they are with bottom jokes, bodily fluids and daggy jokes. Jemimah loves them. For probably the same reasons. I don't like their non-linear format, the simple language and the short chapters. On the other hand, the books are factual, and they're not dumbed down. Well, they are, but not in the way I'm given to use the phrase. They speak directly to children in a way they love and understand.

There are many modern books written with the same format as Horrible Histories that I do not encourage my daughter to read. Wimpy Kid is an example. I make an exception for Horrible Histories books and telly programmes though because Jemimah consistently demonstrates that she is learning real history from them. It may have a bias different to the one I am teaching her in school, but that can only be a good thing, I suppose.

What do you think? Are Horrible Histories twaddle to be avoided at all costs, or does the series have merit? I'm on the side of the latter. Jemimah's narration this afternoon just confirmed it for me.

I'd like to hear your thoughts, though. What do you say?

6 comments:

Erin said...

well my experience is the same as yours. At first my inner CM dismissed them as 'twaddle' but then.. the boys read some and started spouting off information, so I revised my opinion. How do you watch on telly, is it a youtube?

Ruby said...

Luvly!

Jeanne said...

No, it's on free to air telly most nights, I believe.

Therese said...

This is the second blog post I have read about horrible histories. Going to look into getting then.

Melissa said...

Oh Jeanne,
I am so anxious to hear your thoughts on Exploring Creation with A & P! Please do let us know what you and J think of it as you progress!
Can't wait to view one of these Horrible Histories ~ sounds right up the alley of one of my kiddos ;)

Sarah said...

My children enjoy Horrible Histories. We read the books and haven't watched the videos. I'll have to check those out on youtube. Here is how I use Horrible Histories. When we start a new time period in history, I have my son read the H.H. as an introduction to what we will be learning that term.

Post a Comment

I'd love you to leave me a message. Tell me what you like - and what you don't. Just remember that this is what we do in our family - it doesn't have to be what you do in yours...

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Wow! You haven't really read to the bottom of the page, have you? Goodness, thank you!